A Matter of Opinion


Writer’s blog: stardate: 03.05.2013

It’s been a big month for my self-publishing – the biggest in terms of downloads. Rope Enough (The First Romney and Marsh File) was price-matched by Amazon to £0.00 on the 9th April. In the month of April it was downloaded just under 25,000 times. As I’ve highlighted before, there’s no money in that for me, just plenty of free publicity, which to my mind has been well worth it. Things have started to tail off a bit now – Rope Enough was in the top ten free downloads for most of the month, but has since slipped to fifteen.  Of course, it’s to be expected. All good things come to an end and I am essentially still a nobody in publishing terms – a yesterday’s-news-is-today’s-chip-wrapper type of author. It’s not like I have a big fan-base to rely upon.

One very welcome upshot of these downloads has been that those who have gone on to read the book and then taken the time and trouble to comment on Amazon have generally left very encouraging comments. (One gentleman did say that he found the read tedious and would not be recommending it, but at least he didn’t torpedo me completely – he still gave the book a charitable three stars.)

All writers want their work to be well-received. I would venture to say that critical acclaim is more important to an aspiring writer than money (most of us have got jobs anyway). I’m finally getting the kind of feedback that I’ve been after – objective, critical, helpful, insightful and honest. And if I’d seriously considered the possibility of that I might have been a little more anxious. Amazon readers know what they like and they are nobody’s fools.

Something that I have noticed with some bafflement on Amazon is that authors rarely respond to readers reviews and comments – one or two do, but generally these responses are made to take issue with something in what, to my way of thinking, can only end up being a counter-productive exercise.

In another life I worked at a builders’ merchants. This was thirty years ago and still I remember a poster that we had on the office wall – No-One Ever Won An Argument With A Customer. And again, I’m reminded of another similar slogan – Customers Might Not Always Be Right, But They are Always the Customer.

As nobodies, we self-published authors must seek to take every opportunity to engage with our readers positively, politely and constructively, mustn’t we? Doesn’t that just make good sense? If someone is going to take the time and trouble to read our books, more often than not pay for the privilege, and then go on to leave constructive feedback, is it not at least good manners as well as good customer relations to acknowledge what a reader has done for us? I could be wrong, but I get the idea – don’t ask me where from – that authors, even the self-published variety, have this idea that because we are providing free or cheap books for people to read, it is the readers who should be grateful to us. That’s not the way I see it.

I understand that some ‘real’ authors don’t indulge in responding to reviews. Maybe they think that with their traditional publishing deals and their huge loyal fan-bases they don’t need to. Maybe they’re right. Maybe they don’t even look at their reviews – perhaps the arrogance exists that ordinary readers’ opinions of their work, as opposed to the opinions of industry critics, don’t really count for much. Then again, maybe I’ve got that wrong. What I do know is that it counts for me. It matters to me. It matters enough for me to at least say thank you. I even found something nice to say to the guy who didn’t like my book  (I offered to include some pictures, although the artwork would have to be my own and if my humour might come across sometimes as childish you should see my drawings – think stick men).

Fortunately, in addition to seeing this opportunity for interaction as simple common-sense I am also enjoying the experience. I have already had some thoroughly enjoyable and enlightening exchanges with readers – and by no means have all these exchanges been based upon gushingly positive critiques. I’ve learned things about how readers view aspects of my writing – mostly what they don’t like, what grates – and I can take that knowledge and understanding and use it to improve my writing – be a better writer.

Something else that I’ve learned lately – if you’re going to self-publish and you can’t afford a proof-reader, you’d better be bloody thorough about it yourself.

6 thoughts on “A Matter of Opinion

  1. Hello Oliver,
    I havn`t been able to find other replies / messages so if this is going over the same old things just delete it! First I admit downloading for free, however I would not have minded paying for it ( no I wont send you a cheque ) as it was a good read.
    It now seems wrong to go into critical mode but you did ask. I can`t see two lads like your offenders hitting each other hard enough to convince medical staff, and I didn`t go back over it but at one point I think one of them at least was left bleeding. Could they not have been blindfolded and gagged with tape, or some other idea, which could have been done just before leaving them.
    I enjoyed the book and will now download the next, even!! if I have to pay
    Regards Pete.

    • Hi Pete,
      Thanks for getting in touch.
      It’s always good to learn that someone has enjoyed the book, thanks.
      You have raised a very good point and something that I had not considered. On reflection, perhaps your suggestion might have worked better. I can only remember at the time thinking that because of the the serious nature of what surrounded their activity, they had to make it look as authentic as possible. That might start to bother me now. Thanks 🙂
      I’ll be interested to see what you make of the second book. If you are a member of Amazon Prime you can download it for free. If not, the triplets thank you for the contribution to their nappy fund.

  2. Just got a new kindle and have been trying out the fantastic range of free titles, one of which was your “Rope Enough” novel. I have to say I really enjoyed it. In a very competitive market you’ve written a pacy interesting character-led story, and more kudos to you for self-editing. I read a lot of crime fiction and will happily recommend your book. Good luck with your future writing – you have one more convert 🙂

    • Hi Kathleen
      Thanks very much for taking the time and trouble to let me know that you enjoyed Rope Enough. It’s always pleasing to learn that a reader has taken a chance and not been disappointed. Wait till I tell my mum that a fellow quilter got in touch. Best wishes.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s